Six Factors to Consider Prior to Choosing an Electronic Enclosure
Written by: Teresa Kouch, Marketing
Choosing the right enclosure maybe as important as selecting the right product. An electronic enclosure, also known as housing, helps protect the circuit board allowing it to function properly. Elements (e.g. water, wind, dust, dirt, heat, cold, humidity, and chemicals) in the surrounding environment could damage or deteriorate the product.
For example, large temperature variations between the inside and outside of the enclosure can result in pressure differences that may create a vacuum and draw water through the fittings or component and gasket seals. Or when moist air reaches its dew point, it can no longer hold its form and forms moisture droplets being formed on any available surfaces. This is called condensation. When temperatures are below freezing, it will condense into frost. After time, corrosion occurs and causes electrical resistance, which in turn generates additional heat, product performance problems, rusting, increasing risk of circuit shorting out, and arcing and sparking incidences.
Here are six factors to think about before choosing an enclosure:
- Environment
- Application
- Thermal management requirements
- Enclosure performance standards
- Material
- Size
ENVIRONMENT
To determine which enclosure offers the best protection, think of the most important, potential environmental threat. Some questions to think about are:
- What are the environmental conditions?
- What is the primary environmental concern?
- What are the temperature and humidity extremes?
APPLICATION
Application can be associated with market or product. Market applications would be locations such as water treatment plants, parking garages, pools, arenas, repair shops, food plants, etc. Product applications would be physical enclosure requirements such as wall mount, duct mount, easy access, etc.
THERMAL MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS
To maximize the efficiency and lifecycle of products, it is important to be able to manage heat buildup. Whether it’s to dissipate or to add heat, effective thermal management is vital.
ENCLOSURE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS
It is important to understand the enclosure ratings and the level of protection they provide because a single enclosure does not protect against all the elements equally.
To standardize enclosure performance in North America, the National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA), Underwriters Laboratories Inc. (UL), and Canadian Standards Association (CSA) are the commonly recognized standards organization. To standardize enclosure performance internationally, the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) prepares and publishes international standards for all electrical, electronic, and related technologies.
Table 1 describes the NEMA, UL, CSA, and IEC enclosure ratings for both non-hazardous and hazardous locations. For hazardous locations in North America, NEMA has categorized it further and separated it by class, division and groups as seen in Table 2. The class defines the general nature of hazardous material in the surrounding atmosphere, the division defines the probability of hazardous material being present in an ignitable concentration in the surrounding atmosphere, and the group defines the hazardous material in the surrounding atmosphere. The difference between NEMA and UL is that NEMA does not require a third party testing and leaves compliance completely up to the manufacturer.
Table 1: Enclosure Ratings for Non-Hazardous & Hazardous Areas
| NEMA / CSA / UL | IEC | NEMA | CSA | UL |
| NON-HAZARDOUS LOCATIONS | ||||
| TYPE 1 | IP23 |
INDOOR USE General Purpose Protects against contact with the enclosed equipment and against a limited amount of falling dirt. |
INDOOR USE General purpose Protects against accidental contact with live parts. |
INDOOR USE General Purpose Protects against contact with the enclosed equipment and against a limited amount of falling dirt. |
| TYPE 2 | IP30 |
INDOOR USE Drip-Proof Same as NEMA Type 1, including protection against dripping and light splashing of non-corrosive liquids. |
INDOOR USE Drip-Proof Protects against dripping and light splashing of non-corrosive liquids and falling dirt. |
INDOOR USE Drip-Proof Same as UL Type 1, including protection against dripping and light splashing of non-corrosive liquids. |
| TYPE 3 | IP64 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Same as NEMA Type 1, including protection against rain, sleet, snow, and windblown dust. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Protects against rain, snow and windblown dust. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Protects against windblown dust, rain and sleet. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
| TYPE 3R | IP32 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Raintight & Sleet Resistant Same as NEMA Type 3, excluding protection against windblown dust. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Raintight & Sleet Resistant Same as CSA Type 3, excluding protection against windblown dust. |
OUTDOOR USE Raintight & Sleet Resistant Same as UL Type 3, excluding protection against windblown dust. |
| TYPE 3S | - |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Same as NEMA Type 3 and in which the external mechanisms remain operable when ice laden. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Same as CSA Type 3 and in which the external mechanisms remain operable when ice laden. |
OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Sleettight Same as UL Type 3 and in which the external mechanisms remain operable when ice laden |
| TYPE 4 | IP66 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Dusttight & Sleet Resistant Same as NEMA Type 3, including protection against splashing water and hose-directed water. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Dusttight & Sleet Resistant Same as CSA Type 3, including protection against splashing water and hose-directed water. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Dusttight, Raintight & Watertight Same as UL Type 3, excluding protection against sleet. Also, protects against splashing water and by hose-directed water. |
| TYPE 4X | IP66 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Dusttight & Corrosion Resistant Same as NEMA Type 4, including protection against corrosion. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Same as CSA Type 4, including protection against corrosion. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Dusttight & Corrosion Resistant Same as UL Type 4, including protection against corrosion. |
| TYPE 5 | - |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Drip-Proof Same as NEMA Type 2, including protection against settling airborne dust, lint, and fibers. |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Drip-Proof Same as CSA Type 2, including protection against settling dust, lint, fibers, and flyings. |
- |
| TYPE 6 | IP67 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Sleet Resistant & Occasionally Submersible Same as NEMA Type 1, including hose-directed water and the entry of water during occasional temporary submersion at a limited depth. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Sleet Resistant & Occasionally Submersible Protects against the entry of water during temporary submersion at a limited depth. Also, will be undamaged by the external formation of ice. |
- |
| TYPE 6P | IP67 |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Sleet Resistant & Prolonged Submersion Same as NEMA Type 6, including protection against the entry of water during prolonged submersion at a limited depth. |
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Watertight, Corrosion Resistant & Prolonged Submersion Same as CSA Type 6, including protection against the entry of water during prolonged submersion at a limited depth and resists extended corrosion. |
- |
| TYPE 12 | IP64 |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Driptight (without knockouts) Protects against fibers, flyings, lint, dust and dirt, and light splashing, seepage, dripping, and external condensation of non-corrosive liquids.Not provided with knockouts. |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Driptight (without knockouts) Protects against fibers, flyings, lint, dust and dirt, and light splashing, seepage, dripping, and external condensation of non-corrosive liquids.Not provided with knockouts. |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Driptight Same as UL Type 2, including protection against dust. |
| TYPE 12K | IP64 |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Driptight (with knockouts) Same as NEMA Type 12, including enclosures constructed with knockouts. |
INDOOR USE Dusttight & Driptight (with knockouts) Same as CSA Type 12, including enclosures constructed with knockouts. |
- |
| TYPE 13 | IP65 |
INDOOR USE Oiltight & Dusttight Same as NEMA Type 5, including protection against oil. |
INDOOR USE Oiltight & Dusttight Same as CSA Type 5, including protection against oil. |
INDOOR USE Oiltight & Dusttight Same as UL Type 12, including protection against oil. |
| HAZARDOUS LOCATIONS | ||||
| TYPE 7 | - |
INDOOR USE Class I, Group A, B, C or D Explosion-proof, graded per atmospheric group. |
- | - |
| TYPE 8 |
-
|
INDOOR OR OUTDOOR USE Class I, Group A, B, C or D Explosion-proof, graded per atmospheric group. |
- | - |
| TYPE 9 | - |
INDOOR USE Class II, Group E, F or G Explosion-proof, graded per atmospheric group. |
- | - |
Table 2: NEMA Classes, Divisions & Groups for Hazardous Areas
| CLASS | GROUPS | ||
|
Class I
|
Locations where flammable gases or vapors are present in the air in quantities sufficient to produce explosive or ignitable mixtures. | Group A | Acetylene |
| Group B | Acrolein (inhibited), butadiene, ethylene oxide, hydrogen, manufactured gases containing >30% hydrogen (by volume), propylene oxide2 | ||
| Group C | Acetaldehyde, allyl alcohol, n-butyraldehyde, carbon monoxide, crotonaldehyde, cyclopropane, diethyl ether, diethylamine, epichlorohydrin, ethylene, ethylenimine, hydrogen sulfide, morpholine, 2-nitropropane, tetrahydrofuran, unsymmetrical dimethyl hydrazine (UDMH 1, 1-dimethyl hydrazine) | ||
| Group D | Acetic acid, acetone, acrylonitrile, ammonia, benzene, butane, 1-butanol (butyl alcohol), 2-butanol (secondary butyl alcohol), n-butyl acetate, isobutyl acetate, sec-butyl alcohol, di-isobutylene, ethane, ethanol (ethyl alcohol), ethyl acetate, ethyl acrylate (inhibited), ethylene diamine (anhydrous), ethylene dichloride, gasoline, heptanes, hexanes, isoprene, isopropyl ether, mesityl oxide, methane (natural gas), methanol (methyl alcohol), 3-methyl-1-butanol (isoamyl alcohol), methyl ethyl ketone, 2-methyl-1-propanol (isobutyl alcohol), 2-methyl-2-propanol (tertiary butyl alcohol), petroleum naptha, pyridine, octanes, pentanes, 1-pentanol (amyl alcohol), propane, 1-propanol (propyl alcohol), 2-propanol, (isopropyl alcohol), propylene, styrene, toluene, vinyl acetate, vinyl chloride, xylenes | ||
| Class II | Locations where combustible or conductive dusts are present in sufficient quantity to cause hazard. | Group E | Combustible metal dusts, including aluminum, magnesium and their commercial alloys or other combustible dusts whose particle size, abrasiveness and conductivity present similar hazards in connection with electrical equipment. |
| Group F | Carbonaceous dusts, coal black, charcoal, coal or coke dusts that have more than 8% total entrapped volatiles or dusts that have been sensitized by other material so they present an explosion hazard. | ||
| Group G | Flour dust, grain, wood, plastic and chemicals. | ||
| Class III | Locations where easily ignitable fibers or flyings are not normally in suspension in the air in quantities to produce ignitable mixtures. | Group classifications are not applied to this class. | |
| DIVISION | |||
| Division 1 |
Location where the probability of the atmosphere being hazardous is high by underwriting standards. ;bull; Hazardous concentrations exist continuously, intermittently, or periodically under normal operating conditions. • Hazardous concentrations exist frequently due to of repair, maintenance operations or leakage of equipment. • Breakdown of equipment or process failure might simultaneously release hazardous concentrations of flammable gas, vapors, or dust and cause failure of electrical equipment. |
||
| Division 2 |
Location that is presumed to be hazardous only in abnormal situations. • Areas in which flammable liquids or gases are handled, processed, or used but are normally confined in closed containers or closed systems. • Areas that are rendered non-hazardous by forced ventilation, which would become hazardous if the ventilating equipment failed. • Areas adjacent to Division 1 areas in which hazardous concentration of vapors or gases could be communicated unless prevented by positive ventilation with adequate safeguards against ventilation failure. • Areas in which dust layers accumulate and maybe ignited by electrical equipment. |
||
Table 3: IEC Enclosure Ratings
| # | First Number: Solid Object Protection | Second Number: Liquid Protection |
| 0 | No protection | No protection |
| 1 | Objects ≥ 50 mm diameter | Vertically falling water drops |
| 2 | Objects ≥ 12.5 mm diameter | Spray of up to 15º vertical |
| 3 | Objects ≥ 2.5 mm diameter | Spray of up to 60º vertical |
| 4 | Objects ≥ 1.0 mm diameter | Light spray, all directions |
| 5 | Dust-protected with limited ingress | Light jets of water, all directions |
| 6 | Dusttight | Jets of water, all directions |
| 7 | - | Temporary water immersion |
| 8 | - | Continuous water immersion |
MATERIAL
Deciding on the appropriate material for the enclosure, potential environmental threats and application location should be considered. Enclosures are constructed of metals (eg. aluminum, steel) or non-metallic materials (eg. plastic, fiberglass), depending on application performance requirements as seen in Table 4. Table 5 describes the advantages and disadvantages of each enclosure material.
Table 4: Application Performance & Enclosure Materials Application Performance Enclosure Materials
| Application Performance | Enclosure Materials |
| Standard Enclosure |
• Rugged drip-proof PVC • General Purpose PVC |
| Airtight Enclosure |
• Rugged ABS/Polycarbonate • UL94-HB Flame Rated |
| Watertight Enclosure |
• Fiberglass • Polycarbonate |
| Other Enclosure |
• Aluminum • Steel |
Table 5: Advantages & Disadvantages of Enclosure Materials
| Material | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Extruded Aluminum |
• Lighter than steel. • Easier to modify. • Not prone to rust. |
• Moderate cost. |
| Stainless Steel |
• Performance improves with a powder paint finish. • Resist corrosion. |
• Typically will not receive a corrosion resistance (“X”) rating. • High cost. |
| Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) Plastic |
• Shiny, impervious surface. • Impact resistance and toughness. • Impact resistance can be amplified. • Impact resistance does not fall off rapidly at lower temperatures. • Resistant to aqueous acids, alkalis, concentrated hydrochloric and phosphoric acids, alcohols and animal, vegetable and mineral oils • Soluble in esters, ketones and ethylene dichloride. • Contains electrical insulation properties. • Provides resilience even at low temperatures. • Temperature range: 0° F - 125° F • Recyclable. • Meets NEMA 4X ratings but not UL/CSA. • Low cost. |
• Degraded (dissolve) when exposed to acetone. |
| Polycarbonate Plastic |
• Excellent impact resistance. • Temperature range: -31° F - 180° F. • Good dimensional stability & electrical properties • Can be formulated to offer superior fire retention & UV stability. • Good corrosion resistance in some acidic surroundings • Typically a Type 4X rating. • Low to moderate price. |
• Not suitable for environments with strong alkalis & organic solvents. |
| Polyester (PBT) Plastic |
• Moderate price • Lightweight • High impact resistance • Excellent electrical properties • Superior chemical & moisture resistance. • Temperature range: -40° F - 248° F |
• Less impact resistance in cold weather. • Direct sunlight might cause a slight yellowing of the material. |
| Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Plastic |
• Good electrical and insulation properties over a wide temperature range. • Inherent fire safety. • Excellent durability. • Long-life expectancy. • Easy processing characteristics to achieve desired specification for end-products. • Cost-effectiveness • Recyclable • Highly resistant to degradation by UV light • Cheap • Can be made softer & more flexible. |
• Not recommended for use above 70° C, although it can be taken to 80° C for short periods. • Sensitive to UV and oxidative degradation. • Limited thermal capability. • Thermal decomposition evolves HCI. • Higher density than many plastics. |
| Fiberglass |
• Can consist of a heavy outer layer gel coating. • Offers exceptional protection. • Available in many colors. • High impact strength and rigidity. • Temperature range: -31° F - 300° F. • Excellent dimensional stability & electrical properties. • Terrific moisture & overall chemical resistance. • Cost-effective alternative for corrosive environments. |
• Marks and scratches easily. • Could give off toxic fumes; therefore, must be certified by NSF. • Prone to cracking if any heavy objects fall on it.< • Expensive for non-corrosive environments. |
SIZE
When specifying, enclosure size needs to be considered. Some questions to think about are:
- Where will the equipment be mounted?
- Does your application have specific enclosure location requirements?
It is essential to look at all six determinates – environment, application, thermal management requirements, enclosure performance standards, material, and size – prior to choosing an enclosure. Understanding all six factors will help you make a better choice when it comes to choosing the correct enclosure for the job. In essence, it will promote safety, define minimum levels of product performance, and minimize future maintenance expenses.
Simply visit www.critical-environment.com, subscribe to CETCI Magazine Blog, find us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter: @cetci, connect with us on LinkedIn, connect with us on Flickr, or subscribe to our RSS feed.

Contact Us
Login
Where to Buy


